When staying at Commack Inn, located at 2231 Jericho Turnpike, Commack, NY 11725, guests are treated to more than just comfortable and affordable accommodations, they’re also just minutes away from some of Long Island’s top-rated restaurants. Whether you’re craving Italian classics, Spanish tapas, or modern American cuisine, the dining options near this budget-friendly hotel in Commack will satisfy every palate.
In this guide, we’ll explore the best restaurants near Commack Inn, their signature dishes, ambiance, and why they’re worth visiting. Plus, we’ll share insider tips on making the most of your Long Island dining experience.
1. Arlo Kitchen & Bar – Modern American Excellence
📍 1036 Fort Salonga Road, Northport (10 min drive from Commack Inn)
⭐ 4.5 (419+ reviews) | Upscale Casual
Why It’s a Must-Visit
Just a short drive from Commack Inn, Arlo Kitchen & Bar offers a refined yet relaxed dining experience with a focus on seasonal, locally sourced ingredients. Known for its creative cocktails and beautifully presented dishes, this restaurant is perfect for a date night or special occasion.
Must-Try Dishes
✔ Pan-Seared Scallops – Served with citrus beurre blanc and seasonal vegetables.
✔ Arlo Burger – A gourmet take on the classic, featuring dry-aged beef and truffle aioli.
✔ Craft Cocktails – Don’t miss their signature “Northport Mule”, made with local spirits.
Dining Options
- Dine-in (Reservations recommended)
- Takeaway (Perfect for a cozy meal back at Commack Inn)
Hours: Opens at 5 PM (Closed Mondays)
Pro Tip: Ask the Commack Inn front desk for the best time to visit to avoid crowds.
2. Mannino’s Italian Kitchen & Lounge – Authentic Italian Comfort Food
📍 2158 Jericho Turnpike, Commack (5 min drive from Commack Inn)
⭐ 4.5 (931+ reviews) | Family-Friendly Italian
Why It’s a Must-Visit
A local favorite, Mannino’s serves hearty Italian dishes in a warm, rustic setting. If you’re staying at Commack Inn and craving homemade pasta, wood-fired pizza, or classic veal dishes, this is the place to go.
Must-Try Dishes
✔ Lobster Ravioli – Rich, creamy, and packed with fresh lobster.
✔ Veal Parmigiana – A Long Island classic, perfectly breaded and smothered in marinara.
✔ Tiramisu – House-made and delightfully creamy.
Dining Options
- Dine-in only (Great for family dinners)
Hours: Opens at 11 AM
Pro Tip: If you’re traveling with kids, Mannino’s offers a great children’s menu.
3. MaBella – Cozy Italian Bistro
📍 169 Commack Road, Commack (3 min drive from Commack Inn)
⭐ 4.7 (357+ reviews) | $$ | Intimate & Charming
Why It’s a Must-Visit
For a more intimate Italian dining experience, MaBella is a fantastic choice near Commack Inn. The restaurant focuses on simple yet bold flavors, with dishes made from scratch daily.
Must-Try Dishes
✔ Burrata Salad – Creamy burrata with heirloom tomatoes and basil.
✔ Pappardelle Bolognese – Slow-cooked meat sauce over wide, fresh pasta.
✔ Limoncello Cake – A light, citrusy dessert to end your meal.
Dining Options
- Dine-in
- Kerbside Pickup (Ideal for guests who prefer eating at Commack Inn)
Hours: Opens at 12 PM
Pro Tip: Their weekday lunch specials are a great deal!
4. Sangria 71 – Spanish Tapas & Wine Bar
📍 1095 Jericho Turnpike, Commack (7 min drive from Commack Inn)
⭐ 4.5 (1,100+ reviews) | Vibrant & Social
Why It’s a Must-Visit
If you love shared plates and bold flavors, Sangria 71 is a must-visit. This Spanish tapas bar near Commack Inn offers a lively atmosphere, perfect for groups or a fun night out.
Must-Try Dishes
✔ Patatas Bravas – Crispy potatoes with spicy aioli.
✔ Seafood Paella – A saffron-infused masterpiece with fresh seafood.
✔ Red Sangria – Made with fresh fruit and Spanish wine.
Dining Options
- Dine-in
- Kerbside Pickup
Hours: Opens at 12 PM
Pro Tip: Visit during happy hour for discounted tapas and drinks!
Why Staying at Commack Inn Puts You Near the Best Dining
✔ Convenience – All restaurants are within 10 minutes of the hotel.
✔ Variety – From Italian to Spanish to modern American, there’s something for everyone.
✔ Quality – Each restaurant has consistently high ratings from locals and visitors.
Tips for Dining Near Commack Inn
- Make Reservations – Popular spots like Arlo Kitchen & Bar and Mannino’s can get busy.
- Ask the Front Desk – The staff at Commack Inn can recommend hidden gems.
- Try Takeout – Many places offer kerbside pickup, perfect for a relaxed meal in your room.
Final Thoughts
Whether you’re staying at Commack Inn for business, family travel, or a weekend getaway, the nearby dining scene ensures you’ll enjoy delicious, memorable meals. From Italian comfort food at Mannino’s to Spanish tapas at Sangria 71, there’s no shortage of fantastic options.
Ready to book your stay and explore Commack’s culinary delights?
📞 Call: +1 (631) 717-2001
📧 Email: [email protected]
🌐 Visit: Commack Inn Official Website
*Check-in: 4:00 PM | Check-out: 11:00 AM*
Bon appétit and happy travels! 🍷🍝
