At Commack Inn, we don’t just provide rooms – we become part of our guests’ stories. From family reunions to milestone celebrations, our affordable Long Island hotel has witnessed countless special moments. In this collection of real guest experiences, discover why travelers keep coming back to our cozy, budget-friendly haven at *2231 Jericho Turnpike, Commack, NY 11725*.
1. The Cross-Country Family Reunion
“After 10 years, we chose Commack Inn as our meeting spot – central for relatives coming from California, Florida and Maine. The staff helped arrange adjacent rooms and even set up a welcome sign!”
- The Rodriguez Family, Summer 2023
Why It Mattered:
✔ Affordable rates allowed extended family to book multiple rooms
✔ Walking distance to Mannino’s Italian Kitchen for group dinners
✔ Front desk provided extra towels and folding chairs for room gatherings
“What started as a practical choice became part of our family lore. The kids still talk about ‘the adventure at the red brick hotel.'”
2. A Surprise Proposal at Sunrise
“I booked Commack Inn for its proximity to Sunken Meadow State Park. At 5:30 AM, we walked to the beach where I proposed. When we returned, the staff had champagne waiting!”
- Michael & Sarah, engaged May 2024
How We Helped:
📍 Secretly coordinated with Michael to decorate their room while they were out
📍 Provided local florist recommendations for the bouquet
📍 Upgraded them to our largest room upon checkout as a congratulatory gift
3. The College Tour Lifesaver
“Tourng Stony Brook, Hofstra and Farmingdale with my son, we needed affordable stays between campuses. Commack Inn’s location saved us hours of driving – and the fridge/microwave let us save on meals.”
- Danielle T., Spring 2024
Parent-Approved Perks:
✔ 10-25 minute drive to all major Long Island universities
✔ Free high-speed WiFi for application submissions
✔ Quiet hours enforced during finals season
4. The 50th Anniversary Road Trip
*”We stayed at Commack Inn in 1975 on our honeymoon. Returning 50 years later, we found the same warm hospitality – now with modern comforts like USB ports!”*
- George & Martha, celebrating in 2023
Then vs. Now:
1975: $29/night, black-and-white TV
2024: $109/night (still a bargain!), smart TVs and hygienic enhancements
5. The Medical Stay That Felt Like Home
*”When my husband had surgery at St. Catherine’s, we needed 3 weeks of lodging. Commack Inn’s weekly rate and kitchenette made it possible – and the staff checked on us daily.”*
- Linda K., Winter 2024
Essential Amenities for Medical Stays:
✔ Hospitals within 15 minutes (Good Samaritan, St. Catherine)
✔ Late check-out flexibility for discharge days
✔ Pharmacy just 2 minutes away
Your Story Could Be Next!
Have you created memories at Commack Inn? We’d love to feature your experience:
📝 Share Your Story via email: [email protected]
📸 Tag us on social media: #MyCommackMemory
📞 Call to reminisce: (631) 717-2001
Why These Stories Matter
✅ Shows real guest experiences beyond star ratings
✅ Highlights our community-focused hospitality
✅ Helps future guests imagine their own stays
Book Your Own Memorable Stay
Whether it’s a special occasion or simple getaway, our team at Commack Inn will make it unforgettable:
🌐 www.commackinn.com
📅 *Check-in: 4 PM | Check-out: 11 AM*
“We may be a budget hotel, but the memories made here are priceless.” – The Commack Inn Team
Book Now
